No aggregated customer-review data for Every Man Jack yet — check reviews directly on their site.
DTCetc score
Every Man Jack87/100
Dr. Squatch65/100
The DTCetc Face-Off Beauty Updated July 2026
Every Man Jack vs Dr. Squatch
Every Man Jack and Dr. Squatch both cater to men who prioritize clean, natural, and effective personal care products. Every Man Jack focuses on using naturally derived and plant-based ingredients, while Dr. Squatch was born out of a need for natural soap that didn't dry out men's skin. Both brands offer a wide range of products, from body wash to hair care, that cater specifically to men's needs. Whether it's Every Man Jack's passion for the outdoors or Dr. Squatch's dedication to creating a better bar, these brands provide healthy and affordable options for men who want to take care of themselves and the world around them.
Photography: Every Man Jack product imagery Photography: Dr. Squatch product imagery
Customer rating
Every Man Jack—
Dr. Squatch4.5★ 28,302
Typical prices
Every Man Jack$8–$59.50
Dr. Squatch$14–$51
Pricing tier
Every Man Jack$$$$
Dr. Squatch$$$
The verdict
Which should you pick?
The bottom lineEvery Man Jack scores higher on editorial quality (85 vs. 70) and sustainability (82 vs. 70), making it the better choice for eco-conscious shoppers willing to pay a modest premium. Dr. Squatch offers a slightly lower price range and faster standard shipping (3-7 vs. 5-7 business days), appealing to budget-focused buyers who prioritize speed. Both have identical 30-day return policies, but Every Man Jack explicitly provides return labels while Dr. Squatch's label policy is unstated.
Key differences at a glance
- Every Man Jack scores 87/100 editorially vs. Dr. Squatch at 65/100, with Every Man Jack leading on both quality (85 vs. 70) and sustainability (82 vs. 70).
- Every Man Jack's price range is $8–$59.50 vs. Dr. Squatch at $14–$51, giving Every Man Jack more budget-friendly entry points.
- Dr. Squatch standard US shipping takes 3–7 business days vs. Every Man Jack's 5–7 business days; Dr. Squatch offers 2-day expedited shipping vs. Every Man Jack's 2–3 business days.
- Every Man Jack explicitly states return shipping labels are provided; Dr. Squatch's return policy mentions a 30-day window but does not specify label provision.
- Every Man Jack emphasizes plant-based and naturally derived ingredients as core positioning; Dr. Squatch focuses on all-natural soap without chemicals but offers a broader product range (colognes, beard oils, shave kits)
Still weighing it up? Save this comparison & get deals on both →
From 28,302+ published customer reviews
What customers actually say
I like pine tar soap the smell is great and it feels fresh and clean
Dr. Squatch verified buyer · via Okendo (verified reviews on drsquatch.com, Pine Tar Soap bes 4.5 28,302 reviews · via Okendo (verified reviews on drsquatch.com, Pine Tar Soap bes
Squatchers consistently praise Dr. Squatch's Pine Tar bar for its standout natural scent and the fresh, genuinely clean feel it leaves on the skin.
Customers love
- Distinctive, long-lasting masculine scent
- Leaves skin feeling fresh and thoroughly clean
- Natural ingredients / no harsh chemicals
- Softens skin and works well even as a hair wash
Summarized from each brand's own published customer reviews. We never republish full reviews — read them all at the source.
Shop the face-off
Most-loved pieces, side by side
Every Man Jack's most-loved
Dr. Squatch's most-loved
Every Man Jack typical prices$8–$59.50
Dr. Squatch typical prices$14–$51
At a Glance
| Comparison Between |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Beauty | Beauty |
| Speciality | Bath & Body, Skin Care | Personal Care |
| DTCetc Score | 87/100 | 65/100 |
| Customer rating | — | 4.5★ · 28,302 |
| Typical price range | $8–$59.50 | $14–$51 |
| Free shipping | Free over $50 | — |
| Return window | 30 days | 30 days |
| Stereotype | Eco-conscious | Naturalist |
| Pricing Rating | $$$$$
This brand is premium priced
| $$$$$
This brand is moderately priced
|
| Sustainability Score | 82/100
This brand scores excellent in sustainability
| 70/100
This brand scores good in sustainability
|
| Quality Score | 85/100
This brand scores excellent for product quality
| 70/100
This brand scores good for product quality
|
Want more comparisons like Every Man Jack vs Dr. Squatch?
Join free for the latest brands, comparisons & deals.
In the wild
Both brands, up close
Who shops at Every Man Jack Vs. Dr. Squatch
Who shops at Every Man Jack
Men who prioritize clean, naturally derived, and sustainably produced personal care products are the target audience for Every Man Jack. These customers appreciate the brand's commitment to using plant-based ingredients and providing effective and affordable products that are free from harmful chemicals and not tested on animals.
Who shops at Dr. Squatch
Dr. Squatch appeals to men who want natural grooming products that are healthy and effective. These customers appreciate the honest approach and wide range of products, from soap and hair care to colognes and shave kits, that cater specifically to men's needs.
Every Man Jack Vs. Dr. Squatch The Pros
Every Man Jack's Pros
- Uses naturally derived and plant-based ingredients
- 30-day return policy for unworn, unused items with tags and original packaging
- Provides return shipping labels for accepted returns
- Customer support available at support@everymanjack.com
Dr. Squatch's Pros
- Dr. Squatch soap is all-natural and doesn't contain chemicals, making it worth the price
- Excellent customer service.
- The soap smells great and great for skin
Every Man Jack's shipping policy Vs. Dr. Squatch's Shipping Policy
Every Man Jack's shipping policy
Every Man Jack offers shipping to both the US and Canada. Standard shipping within the US takes 5-7 business days and costs $15, but orders over $25 qualify for $5 ground shipping. Orders over $50 receive free standard shipping. Expedited shipping is available for $15 and takes 2-3 business days. Shipping to Canada is a flat rate of $25 for 5-7 business days, but orders over $25 qualify for $20 ground shipping. Orders over $50 receive $5 ground shipping.
Dr. Squatch's shipping policy
Dr. Squatch offers both domestic and international shipping options. For domestic shipping within the US, standard ground shipping typically takes 3-7 business days, while priority shipping takes 3-4 business days and expedited shipping takes 2 business days. Large orders are shipped via UPS or FedEx Ground shipping, and customers will receive a shipping confirmation email 1-3 business days after their package has shipped. For Canadian customers, standard ground shipping also takes 3-7 business days, and orders are not subject to any taxes or duties upon delivery. International shipping is available for select countries, with shipping rates calculated at checkout based on the country and size of the order. Orders shipped to the United Kingdom, Mexico, Australia, New Zealand, Hong Kong, or member states of the EU will be shipped DDP, while all other countries will be shipped DDU. Dr. Squatch covers the cost of safely transporting products to the agreed-upon destination, but taxes and duties may be required for packages entering certain countries.
Every Man Jack's return policy vs Dr. Squatch's Return Policy
Every Man Jack's return policy
30-day return policy from receipt of item. Items must be unworn, unused, with tags, in original packaging, and accompanied by receipt or proof of purchase. Contact support@everymanjack.com to initiate a return and receive a return shipping label.
Dr. Squatch's return policy
Dr. Squatch offers a 30-day return policy for their products. If a customer is not 100% satisfied with their purchase, they can contact the company within 30 days of the order delivery date to initiate a return. The company will refund the customer's order if they are not a great match.
Keep comparing
