Is Bobbie or Yumi rated higher?

Bobbie has a higher DTCetc score of 87/100 compared to Yumi at 80/100.

What do customers say about Bobbie vs Yumi?

Bobbie holds 4.88★ across 868 published customer reviews. See the full breakdown of what customers praise and criticize for both brands on DTCetc.

Bobbie vs Yumi

Bobbie and Yumi cater to different needs of modern parents. Bobbie focuses on providing high-quality and accessible formula options, offering peace of mind and support to parents. On the other hand, Yumi appeals to health-conscious parents who prioritize organic and nutrient-dense meals for their babies and toddlers. Yumi's commitment to using fresh, organic ingredients and avoiding harmful additives aligns with the values of customers who want to provide their children with the best possible nutrition. Both brands offer unique solutions for parents seeking the best for their children.

Bobbie

Yumi

DTCetc score

Bobbie87/100

Yumi80/100

Customer rating

Bobbie4.88★ 868

Yumi—

Typical prices

Bobbie$1–$280

Yumi—

Pricing tier

Bobbie—

Yumi$$$$

The verdict

Which should you pick?

Bobbie

★★★★¾ 4.88 · 868 reviews

87/100

Best forModern parents, quality, accessibility

★ Quality 95/100 Visit Bobbie →

Yumi

80/100

Best forParents, toddlers

★ Quality 90/100 Visit Yumi →

The bottom lineBobbie is a formula-focused brand best for parents seeking organic infant formula with fast shipping and strong customer service (4.88/5 stars), though returns are limited to Starter Bundles only. Yumi targets families with older children wanting organic prepared foods, offers more flexible returns (24 hours), and emphasizes expert-guided nutrition—but at a higher price tier and without the subscription discounts Bobbie provides.

Key differences at a glance

Bobbie specializes in infant formula with probiotic and vitamin supplements; Yumi makes prepared organic baby food for older children—different product categories for different ages.
Bobbie's editorial quality score is 95 vs. Yumi's 90, though Yumi matches Bobbie's sustainability score at 90 vs. Bobbie's 80.
Bobbie prices range $1–$280 across products; Yumi is positioned in the higher pricing tier (70/100) with free shipping over $75.
Bobbie offers 10% off first subscriptions and a 30-day guarantee on Starter Bundles only; Yumi provides free shipping on orders over $75 with code FREESHIP.
Bobbie ships in 3–6 business days but has no returns for unused products except Starter Bundles; Yumi allows returns within 24 hours of delivery with potential full or partial refunds.
Bobbie customers praise fast shipping and responsive service (4.88/5 stars, 868 reviews); Yumi is guided by nutrition and pediatric experts but lacks published customer review data.
Bobbie's return policy is restrictive (all sales final except Starter Bundles); Yumi's 24-hour return window is more customer-friendly but requires photo evidence and customer service contact.

From 868+ published customer reviews

What customers actually say

Shipping and service were fine, I am dissatisfied with the product

Bobbie verified buyer · via Yotpo

4.88 868 reviews · via Yotpo

Bobbie excels in shipping speed and customer service, though some customers have concerns about product fit and delivery timing.

Customers love

Fast, reliable shipping that consistently arrives on time
Responsive and helpful customer service via multiple channels
USDA organic formula meeting European standards
Easy ordering and subscription management

Watch out for

Occasional shipping delays causing customers to seek alternatives
Product may not be suitable for all babies

No aggregated customer-review data for Yumi yet — check reviews directly on their site.

Summarized from each brand's own published customer reviews. We never republish full reviews — read them all at the source.

Shop the face-off

Most-loved pieces, side by side

Bobbie's most-loved

Organic Infant Formula $104

Organic Gentle® Infant Formula $128

Organic Probiotic Drops $26

Bobbie typical prices$1–$280

At a Glance

Comparison Between	Bobbie	Yumi
Category	Baby	Baby
Speciality	Feeding	Feeding
DTCetc Score	87/100	80/100
Customer rating	4.88★ · 868	—
Typical price range	$1–$280	—
Free shipping	—	Free
Return window	14 days	—
Stereotype	Parent	Health-conscious
Pricing Rating	$$$$$ This brand is affordably priced	$$$$$ This brand is moderately priced
Sustainability Score	80/100 This brand scores excellent in sustainability	90/100 This brand scores excellent in sustainability
Quality Score	95/100 This brand scores excellent for product quality	90/100 This brand scores excellent for product quality

Who shops at Bobbie Vs. Yumi

Who shops at Bobbie

Bobbie is for parents and caregivers of infants.

More about Bobbie →

Who shops at Yumi

YUMI is for families with children seeking healthier food options.

More about Yumi →

Bobbie Vs. Yumi The Pros

Bobbie's Pros

Offers USDA Organic Probiotic Drops
Provides Organic Vitamin D Drops
10% discount on first-time subscriptions
30-day satisfaction guarantee on Starter Bundle purchases
Refer a friend program offering $30 credit

More about Bobbie →

Yumi's Pros

Uses organic ingredients sourced from trusted partners
Guided by a board of nutrition and pediatric experts
Offers free shipping on orders over $75 with code FREESHIP
Focuses on high-quality ingredients with purpose

More about Yumi →

Bobbie's shipping policy Vs. Yumi's Shipping Policy

Bobbie's shipping policy

Most Bobbie orders arrive within 3 to 6 business days, with tracking information updating within 72 hours of shipment. Extra time should be allowed for deliveries during national holidays.

More about Bobbie →

Yumi's shipping policy

Hello Yumi offers free shipping within the contiguous United States. There are no shipping costs or deals associated with purchases.Unfortunately, the brand does not offer international shipping at this time.

More about Yumi →

Bobbie's return policy vs Yumi's Return Policy

Bobbie's return policy

All sales are final and Bobbie does not accept returns or exchanges for unused products. Starter Bundle purchases only are eligible for a 30-day satisfaction guarantee allowing full refunds with no return necessary. Damaged products should be reported, and incorrect orders must be reported within 14 days of purchase.

More about Bobbie →

Yumi's return policy

Hello Yumi's return policy allows customers to return their organic baby food delivery within 24 hours of receiving it. Customers must contact customer service to initiate a return and may be required to provide photo evidence for the return. Depending on the reason for the return, customers may be eligible for a full or partial refund. Items that are not eligible for a return will not be accepted. The company typically processes returns within a few days.

More about Yumi →

Keep comparing