DTCetc
ComparisonsAboutSubmit Search
The DTCetc Face-Off Apparel Updated July 2026

Andie vs Summersalt

Andie and Summersalt are both swimwear brands that prioritize comfort and inclusivity for modern women. While Andie focuses on providing a hassle-free shopping experience with well-made and well-cut swimsuits, Summersalt emphasizes body positivity and offers a wide range of sizes and styles. Both brands value customer satisfaction, with Andie providing swimwear experts to assist customers and Summersalt offering installment payment options and free shipping and returns. Whether you're looking for a convenient shopping experience or a celebration of diverse beauty, both Andie and Summersalt have you covered.

Photography: Andie product imagery Photography: Summersalt product imagery

DTCetc score

Andie69/100
Summersalt84/100

Customer rating

Andie4.81★
Summersalt—

Typical prices

Andie$8–$202
Summersalt$10–$649

Pricing tier

Andie$$$$
Summersalt$$$
The verdict

Which should you pick?

Andie
★★★★¾ 4.81
69/100

Best forModern women, hassle-free shoppers, sun-lovers

Visit Andie →
Summersalt
84/100

Best forWomen, body-positive

★ Quality 90/100 Visit Summersalt →

The bottom lineSummersalt scores higher on editorial quality (90 vs 75) and sustainability (90 vs 60), uses data from 1.5M measurements for fit, and offers free 2-day shipping on orders $95+. Andie fulfills faster (1 business day vs standard 3-5 days), has a simpler return policy with no fees, and costs less overall ($8–$170 vs $10–$649). Choose Summersalt for eco-conscious shoppers prioritizing premium quality and fit science; choose Andie for budget-conscious buyers who value quick fulfillment and hassle-free returns.

Key differences at a glance

  • Summersalt's editorial quality score is 90/100 vs Andie's 75/100; Summersalt also scores 90 on sustainability vs Andie's 60.
  • Andie fulfills orders in 1 business day; Summersalt takes 3-5 business days for domestic ground shipping (though 1-2 days available via FedEx).
  • Summersalt offers free 2-day shipping on orders $95+; Andie charges for all shipping options (Standard, Expedited, International).
  • Summersalt's return policy charges an $8 handling fee per mail-in return; Andie's 21-day returns are free with no fees mentioned.
  • Andie's price range is $8–$170; Summersalt ranges $10–$649, positioning it as a premium tier.
  • Andie customers report sizing inconsistencies between styles; Summersalt's fit is based on 1.5M measurements from 10,000 women with no sizing complaints noted.
  • Andie's thicker fabrics are praised for forgiveness but criticized for slow drying; Summersalt emphasizes eco-friendly fabrics designed to last years with no drying concerns mentioned.

Still weighing it up? Save this comparison & get deals on both →

From published customer reviews

What customers actually say

So unbelievably flattering. Shows off my back + glutes without feeling too skimpy for me.

Andie verified buyer · via Okendo
4.81 store rating · via Okendo

Andie Swim earns exceptional ratings for flattering fits, quality construction, and excellent customer service, though sizing can be inconsistent and the thicker fabric dries slowly.

Customers love
  • Highly flattering fit with great coverage, especially for curvy/muscular builds and larger busts
  • Quality construction and comfortable fabric, with thicker options more forgiving than traditional
  • Easy return policy and helpful customer service; true to size with useful size guide
Watch out for
  • Sizing inconsistencies between styles; some tops run small
  • Thicker fabric takes very long to dry even in hot weather
  • Not suitable for all body types; some customers found poor fit for their proportions

No aggregated customer-review data for Summersalt yet — check reviews directly on their site.

Summarized from each brand's own published customer reviews. We never republish full reviews — read them all at the source.

Shop the face-off

Most-loved pieces, side by side

Andie's most-loved
Ava Kimono - Black Stripes Ava Kimono - Black Stripes $124 Aura Palazzo Pants - Oatmeal Aura Palazzo Pants - Oatmeal $148 Aura Palazzo Pants - Black Aura Palazzo Pants - Black $148
Summersalt's most-loved
Summersalt x Weezie Wet Bag Summersalt x Weezie Wet Bag $44 Summersalt x Weezie Small Patterned Toiletry Bag Summersalt x Weezie Small Patterned Toiletry Bag $58 Summersalt x Weezie Patterned Toiletry Bag Trio Summersalt x Weezie Patterned Toiletry Bag Trio $147.90 $174
Andie typical prices$8–$202
Summersalt typical prices$10–$649

At a Glance

Comparison Between
Andie
Andie
Summersalt
Summersalt
Category Apparel Apparel
Speciality Swimwear Clothing, Swimwear
DTCetc Score 69/100 84/100
Customer rating 4.81★ —
Typical price range $8–$202 $10–$649
Free shipping — Free over $95
Return window 21 days 21 days
Stereotype Modern Body-positive
Pricing Rating
$$$$$ This brand is moderately priced
$$$$$ This brand is moderately priced
Sustainability Score
60/100
This brand scores good in sustainability
90/100
This brand scores excellent in sustainability
Quality Score
75/100
This brand scores good for product quality
90/100
This brand scores excellent for product quality
In the wild

Both brands, up close

Andie product photography
Andie
Summersalt product photography
Summersalt
Andie product photography
Andie
Summersalt product photography
Summersalt
Andie product photography
Andie
Summersalt product photography
Summersalt

Who shops at Andie Vs. Summersalt

Who shops at Andie

Andie is a brand that offers well-made and well-cut swimsuits for modern life. Customers who struggle with swimwear shopping and want a hassle-free experience would love Andie. The brand also designs swimsuits with feedback and wear tests from thousands of women, ensuring that every body type and occasion is catered to. Andie's swimsuits are made for life's sunniest moments, allowing customers to spend less time worrying about their swimsuit and more time making memories.

More about Andie →

Who shops at Summersalt

Designed for women seeking well-fitting swimwear.

More about Summersalt →

Andie Vs. Summersalt The Pros

Andie's Pros

  • Orders typically fulfilled within 1 business day
  • Multiple shipping speed options available (Standard 4-5 days, Expedited 2-4 days, International 3-8 days)
  • 21-day return window from delivery date
  • Exchanges available for eligible items
  • Ships to multiple countries
More about Andie →

Summersalt's Pros

  • Iconic fit based on 1.5 million measurements from 10,000 real women
  • Made with eco-friendly fabrics
  • High-quality fabrics designed to last for years
  • Free exchanges within 21 days of delivery
  • Free returns for store credit within 21 days of delivery
More about Summersalt →

Andie's shipping policy Vs. Summersalt's Shipping Policy

Andie's shipping policy

Orders are typically fulfilled within 1 business day. Delivery times vary by shipping type: Standard Shipping takes 4-5 business days, Expedited Shipping takes 2-4 business days, and International Shipping takes 3-8 business days.

More about Andie →

Summersalt's shipping policy

For domestic orders, Summersalt ships via DHL or USPS Ground, which takes 3-5 business days, or FedEx Next Day or 2-Day, which takes 1-2 business days. Orders of $95 and above are eligible for free 2-day shipping. For international orders, Summersalt ships via Express International Shipping which takes 3-6 business days for delivery. Taxes, duties, customs fees, etc. will be applied to the order total at checkout, and international orders are not eligible for free shipping.

More about Summersalt →

Andie's return policy vs Summersalt's Return Policy

Andie's return policy

Orders are eligible for return or exchange within 21 days from delivery date if in original, unworn condition with all tags and liners intact. Final Sale items including underwear are not eligible for return or exchange, and all original shipping costs including duties and taxes are non-refundable.

More about Andie →

Summersalt's return policy

Returns and exchanges must be initiated within 21 days of delivery. Mail-in returns have an $8 handling fee per return label, waived for exchanges or store credit refunds. All items must be unused, pristine condition with original tags and hygienic liners intact. Underwear, bralettes, towels, face coverings, and monogrammed items are final sale.

More about Summersalt →
Keep comparing

People also compare

Cupshe VS Summersalt Cupshe vs Summersalt See comparison →