The DTCetc Face-Off Apparel Updated July 2026

Honeylove vs ThirdLove

Honeylove and ThirdLove are both popular brands that cater to the modern woman who values comfort, quality, and inclusivity in her clothing and lingerie. Honeylove specializes in clothing and shapewear that empowers and flatters all body shapes and sizes, while ThirdLove is known for their high-quality, comfortable bras designed to fit a variety of body shapes and sizes. Both brands prioritize sustainability and ethical production practices, and offer a wide range of sizes to ensure a perfect fit. However, Honeylove goes beyond shapewear and offers a variety of stylish and functional products, while ThirdLove stands out with their innovative fit finder tool and charitable donations. Ultimately, both brands are great choices for the modern woman who wants to feel confident and comfortable while supporting brands that align with her values.

DTCetc score

Honeylove67/100
ThirdLove80/100

Customer rating

Honeylove4.34★
ThirdLove4.68★ 29,962

Typical prices

Honeylove
ThirdLove$5–$74

Pricing tier

Honeylove$$$$
ThirdLove$$$$
The verdict

Which should you pick?

Honeylove
★★★★¼ 4.34
67/100

Best forComfortable, empowering, sustainable

Visit Honeylove →
ThirdLove
★★★★½ 4.68 · 29,962 reviews
80/100

Best forWomen, Plus Size

★ Quality 90/100 Visit ThirdLove →

The bottom lineThirdLove scores higher overall (80 vs. 67) with better quality and sustainability ratings, plus a longer 60-day return window versus Honeylove's 30 days. ThirdLove customers praise fit and service (4.68/5 stars), while Honeylove shoppers report shapewear fit issues despite comfort in bras (4.34/5 stars). Choose ThirdLove for reliable fit and customer support; choose Honeylove if you prioritize body-positive positioning and don't need shapewear.

Key differences at a glance

  • ThirdLove's 60-day return window doubles Honeylove's 30-day policy, giving more time to decide.
  • ThirdLove invented half-cup sizing for improved fit; Honeylove focuses on compression shapewear (Sculptwear) with reported fit inconsistencies.
  • ThirdLove's customer reviews (4.68/5) consistently praise fit and service; Honeylove's (4.34/5) highlight comfort but note shapewear gaps and sizing problems.
  • ThirdLove offers free Fit Stylists to help sizing; Honeylove offers HoneyClub membership with 20% store credit and early sale access.
  • ThirdLove domestic shipping takes 3–7 business days; Honeylove takes 5–9 business days (both offer expedited options).
  • ThirdLove's editorial quality score is 90 vs. Honeylove's 60; ThirdLove's sustainability score is 90 vs. Honeylove's 70.
  • Honeylove's gently worn returns are kept; ThirdLove donates returned gently worn bras to women in need.

Still weighing it up? Save this comparison & get deals on both →

From 29,962+ published customer reviews

What customers actually say

I absolutely love my new bras from Honeylove! I've worn underwire bras for soooo long I didn't know there were bras that were not underwire and would hold me up and feel so comfortable.

Honeylove verified buyer · via Okendo
4.34 store rating · via Okendo

Honeylove bras are highly praised for comfort and support without underwire, though shapewear fit issues and removable pad design frustrate some customers.

Customers love
  • Comfortable, soft underwire-free bras with strong support
  • Great for post-surgery/cancer survivors seeking gentle support
  • No slipping straps, flattering fit, easy to put on/take off
Watch out for
  • Shapewear gaps and poor fit regardless of sizing
  • Removable pads twist and are difficult to adjust
  • High price point not always justified by quality/durability
  • Some fit issues (rubbing armpits, side bars uncomfortable)

I have been searching for comfortable, wireless bras for two years after finishing breastfeeding and I finally found them with ThirdLove.

ThirdLove verified buyer · via Yotpo
4.68 29,962 reviews · via Yotpo

ThirdLove delivers excellent bras with outstanding customer service, though some customers note shipping could be faster and cheaper.

Customers love
  • Comfortable, well-fitting bras in half-cup and wireless styles
  • Responsive, helpful customer service and fit specialists
  • Easy ordering and return process
Watch out for
  • Shipping is slow and expensive, especially to remote areas like Hawaii

Summarized from each brand's own published customer reviews. We never republish full reviews — read them all at the source.

Shop the face-off

Most-loved pieces, side by side

ThirdLove typical prices$5–$74

At a Glance

Comparison Between
Honeylove
Honeylove
ThirdLove
ThirdLove
Category Apparel Apparel
Speciality Underwear Underwear
DTCetc Score 67/100 80/100
Customer rating 4.34 4.68★ · 29,962
Typical price range $5–$74
Free shipping Free over $100 Free over $75
Return window 30 days 60 days
Stereotype Body-positive Modern woman
Pricing Rating
$$$$$ This brand is moderately priced
$$$$$ This brand is moderately priced
Sustainability Score
70/100
This brand scores good in sustainability
90/100
This brand scores excellent in sustainability
Quality Score
60/100
This brand scores good for product quality
90/100
This brand scores excellent for product quality

Who shops at Honeylove Vs. ThirdLove

Who shops at Honeylove

For people seeking shapewear that provides confidence and comfort.

More about Honeylove →

Who shops at ThirdLove

For people seeking well-fitting bras with both comfort and support.

More about ThirdLove →

Honeylove Vs. ThirdLove The Pros

Honeylove's Pros

  • 30-day return window for exchanges or refunds
  • Accepts returns of unworn items tried on over underwear
  • Offers HoneyClub membership with 20% store credit and early sale access
  • Can exchange for new sizes or colors of the same style online
More about Honeylove →

ThirdLove's Pros

  • Invented half cup sizes for better fit
  • Free exchanges and returns for 60 days in the U.S.
  • Returned gently worn bras are donated to women in need
  • Stay-put straps and smooth, supportive design
  • Fit Stylists available to help find the right size or style
More about ThirdLove →

Honeylove's shipping policy Vs. ThirdLove's Shipping Policy

Honeylove's shipping policy

Honeylove offers various shipping options for both domestic and international orders. For domestic orders, the Basic Shipping method takes about 5-9 business days to arrive, while expedited options like 2-day and Overnight are available at checkout for faster delivery. Orders placed before 11 am PT Monday-Friday ship out the same day, while orders placed after 11 am PT Friday - Sunday will ship out on the next business day. Domestic orders over $100 qualify for free shipping, including shipments to Hawaii, Alaska, and armed forces addresses. For international orders, DHL delivery takes approximately 4-10 business days, and shipping costs are calculated daily in the checkout process. Honeylove absorbs about 20% of the cost, and the cost shown includes all local duties and taxes. Note that there is a basic shipping charge of $4.99 for domestic orders below $100.

More about Honeylove →

ThirdLove's shipping policy

For domestic customers in the United States, shipping takes between 3-7 business days for the Continental US, 4-10 business days for Alaska and Hawaii. Standard shipping costs $5, but free shipping is available for orders over $75 through FedEx SmartPost or orders over $50 through Hooked Rewards.For international customers, shipments take 2 weeks and shipping costs vary between $10-25. ThirdLove ships to the UK, Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Japan, Latvia, Lituania, Luxembourg, Malta, Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, and Sweden. Free shipping is available for orders over $200.

More about ThirdLove →

Honeylove's return policy vs ThirdLove's Return Policy

Honeylove's return policy

You may return Sculptwear within 30 days for an exchange or refund to your original form of payment. Returns must be unworn (trying on over underwear is acceptable), in original packaging with tags attached, and free of damages and scents.

More about Honeylove →

ThirdLove's return policy

U.S. customers can exchange or return for free within 60 days. Canadian customers pay $9.99 for return shipping, which is deducted from the refund, and exchanges are not accepted on Canadian orders.

More about ThirdLove →
Keep comparing

People also compare