Compare Milk Makeup and Glossier

Milk Makeup and Glossier are both beloved beauty brands that have gained a loyal following in the industry. Both brands are cruelty-free and offer a range of innovative products. Milk Makeup is known for its high-quality, vegan formulas, while Glossier focuses on enhancing natural beauty with its subtle makeup products. While Milk Makeup has a larger range of skincare options, Glossier has a blog that provides helpful beauty tips. Ultimately, both brands are perfect for those looking for ethical, natural beauty options.

At a Glance

Comparison Between
Milk Makeup
Milk Makeup
Glossier
Glossier
Category Beauty Beauty
Speciality Cosmetics Cosmetics
DTCetc Score 84/100 88.33333333333333/100
Target Audience Young, trendy, diverse Gen-Z, Millennials
Stereotype Eco-conscious Minimalist
Pricing Rating
$$$$$ This brand is moderately priced
$$$$$ This brand is moderately priced
Sustainability Score
90/100
This brand scores excellent in sustainability
90/100
This brand scores excellent in sustainability
Quality Score
90/100
This brand scores excellent for product quality
95/100
This brand scores excellent for product quality

Who shops at Milk Makeup Vs. Glossier

Who shops at Milk Makeup

Milk Makeup is an inclusive brand suitable for all genders, ages, ethnic backgrounds, and abilities. The company strives to have varied shade ranges for all skin makeup products, although there is always room for improvement.

More about Milk Makeup →

Who shops at Glossier

Glossier is a brand that caters to those who want a natural beauty look. Its target audience is Gen-Z and millennials, but its products are suitable for all ages. The brand offers subtle makeup products that provide a “no-makeup” look.

More about Glossier →

Milk Makeup Vs. Glossier The Pros

Milk Makeup's Pros

  • Milk Makeup provides easy to use, “effortless” makeup products. Popular products include the glow oils, sunshine oil, and watermelon brightening mask. The lash primer + Kush mascara is also a great combo for droopy lashes.
  • The Hydro Grip Primer is a good product that provides moisture to the skin and doesn’t contain any parabens.
  • Milk Makeup has a range of stick products, such as the flex foundation stick, lip + cheek stick, kush lip balm, and cooling water stick.
  • Milk Makeup is cruelty free and vegan.
  • The Hydro Grip Primer works nicely on foundations that have issues lasting long or fading.
More about Milk Makeup →

Glossier's Pros

  • Products provide a natural feel of makeup, with sleek packaging that makes users feel bougie.
  • Products have few misses, with favorites such as the Milky Jelly Cleanser and Boy Brow.
  • Website is easy to use and ordering is straightforward.
  • Products come in cute packaging and with testers and stickers.
  • Shipping is quick and customers can opt in or out of getting the pink pouch.
  • Products provide light and clean coverage, with a “no makeup, makeup look”.
  • Variety of products suitable for makeup novices and regular users.
  • Perfume has a unique smell.
More about Glossier →

Milk Makeup Vs. Glossier The Cons

Milk Makeup's Cons

  • The effectiveness of the Hydro Grip Primer is questionable.
  • Some products may not meet expectations, including the kush lip glaze, kush triple brow pen, and blur stick.
  • The primer may not work for everyone.
More about Milk Makeup →

Glossier's Cons

  • The products may not work for everyone, as they are designed for a specific type of skin or style.
  • The prices may be higher than some customers are willing to pay for the quality of the products.
  • The packaging may not be as sturdy or practical as some customers would like.
More about Glossier →

Milk Makeup's shipping policy Vs. Glossier's Shipping Policy

Milk Makeup's shipping policy

Milk Makeup only ships to the US. Domestic orders are processed and delivered within 4 business days, with the option of UPS ground shipping for a flat rate of $8. Free shipping is available for orders over $30. For Hawaii and Alaska, UPS ground shipping is available for a flat rate of $25 for orders over $50, or $33 for orders under that amount.

More about Milk Makeup →

Glossier's shipping policy

For domestic orders in the US, Glossier offers free shipping for orders over $30 and standard shipping takes 5-7 business days. Rush or express shipping can take between 2-3 days, but is currently unavailable due to COVID-19. For international orders, Glossier ships to the UK, Canada, Ireland, Sweden, Denmark, and France. Standard shipping times are 3-5 business days for the UK, 5-10 business days for Canada, 5-7 business days for Ireland and France, and 6-8 business days for Sweden and Denmark. Next business day shipping in the UK can take 1-2 days, but rush/express shipping is currently unavailable.

More about Glossier →

Milk Makeup's return policy vs Glossier's Return Policy

Milk Makeup's return policy

Milk Makeup offers a customer satisfaction guarantee, allowing customers to return any unopened merchandise within 90 days of purchase. To initiate a return or exchange, customers should contact the customer service team. No items are excluded from being returned, and the company does not specify how long it takes to process a return.

More about Milk Makeup →

Glossier's return policy

Glossier's return policy allows customers to return an item within 30 days of purchase. To initiate a return, customers must contact Glossier's team via email and include their order number. Refunds to credit cards can take between 5-10 business days to process. Non-refundable items include any items purchased with a discount code or items purchased through a third-party retailer.

More about Glossier →