DTCetc score
Gorgie76/100
Poppi82/100
The DTCetc Face-Off CPG Updated July 2026
Gorgie vs Poppi
Gorgie and Poppi are both better-for-you, Gen-Z-favorite functional beverages that broke out on TikTok, though they target different needs. Gorgie makes sparkling, zero-sugar energy drinks with green-tea caffeine, L-theanine and B-vitamins, built 'by women, for fun.' Poppi is a prebiotic soda with a splash of juice and apple-cider vinegar, aimed at gut health with low sugar. Pick Gorgie for clean energy; pick Poppi for a soda-style prebiotic treat.
Typical prices
Gorgie—
Poppi$19.95–$29.99
Pricing tier
Gorgie$$
Poppi$$
The verdict
Which should you pick?
The bottom lineGorgie scores slightly lower editorially (76 vs. 82) but positions itself as a zero-sugar energy drink with green tea caffeine and added vitamins, while Poppi is a prebiotic soda alternative with fruit juice. Gorgie is cheaper (pricing tier 40 vs. 35, meaning Poppi is pricier) and offers store credit returns on first-time flavors; Poppi doesn't accept beverage returns except for damaged items. Choose Gorgie if you want a caffeinated wellness drink with minimal ingredients; choose Poppi if you prefer a soda replacement focused on gut health.
Key differences at a glance
- Gorgie contains caffeine from green tea and B vitamins (B6, B12, Biotin); Poppi contains prebiotics and fruit juice with no caffeine.
- Gorgie has zero sugar (0g); Poppi's sugar content is not specified in the fact sheet.
- Gorgie offers store credit for first-flavor returns within 30 days; Poppi does not accept beverage returns except for damaged packages.
- Poppi's editorial quality score is 75 vs. Gorgie's 76; Poppi's overall score is 82 vs. Gorgie's 76.
- Poppi is positioned as a soda alternative for gut health; Gorgie is positioned as an energy drink made by and for women.
- Gorgie ships free on $50+ orders (continental U.S. only); Poppi's shipping costs are not detailed in the fact sheet.
- Poppi is stocked at Whole Foods and appeared on Shark Tank; Gorgie's retail presence is not mentioned.
Still weighing it up? Save this comparison & get deals on both →
Shop the face-off
Most-loved pieces, side by side
Poppi's most-loved
Poppi typical prices$19.95–$29.99
At a Glance
| Comparison Between |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Category | CPG | CPG |
| Speciality | — | Drinks |
| DTCetc Score | 76/100 | 82/100 |
| Typical price range | — | $19.95–$29.99 |
| Free shipping | Free over $50 | — |
| Return window | 30 days | — |
| Stereotype | — | Soda for the gut-curious millennial |
| Pricing Rating | $$$$$
This brand is affordably priced
| $$$$$
This brand is affordably priced
|
| Sustainability Score | 50/100
This brand scores fair in sustainability
| 55/100
This brand scores fair in sustainability
|
| Quality Score | 76/100
This brand scores good for product quality
| 75/100
This brand scores good for product quality
|
Want more comparisons like Gorgie vs Poppi?
Join free for the latest brands, comparisons & deals.
Who shops at Gorgie Vs. Poppi
Who shops at Gorgie
Aimed at people who want a sugar-free energy drink, with the brand positioning itself as made for and by women.
Who shops at Poppi
Poppi is for consumers seeking a soda alternative with added prebiotics.
Gorgie Vs. Poppi The Pros
Gorgie's Pros
- Zero sugar (0g)
- Caffeine sourced from green tea
- Contains L-Theanine, Biotin, and B6 + B12
- Gluten free, vegan, and non-GMO
- No aspartame and a short ingredient list
Poppi's Pros
- Contains prebiotics mixed with fruit juices and sparkling water
- Founded by Allison Ellsworth who wanted a better-tasting soda alternative
- Stocked at Whole Foods
- Featured on Shark Tank with investment from Rohan Oza
Gorgie's shipping policy Vs. Poppi's Shipping Policy
Gorgie's shipping policy
Orders are processed Monday through Friday and ship via FedEx, with free shipping on orders of $50 or more within the continental U.S. Orders may arrive in multiple boxes, and shipping is limited to the continental U.S. (no international shipping yet).
Poppi's shipping policy
Orders are shipped to the exact address entered at checkout. If an order is returned due to an incorrect address, the company is not responsible for return shipping costs.
Gorgie's return policy vs Poppi's Return Policy
Gorgie's return policy
Gorgie offers store credit (not a monetary refund) for a first try of a new flavor, limited to one case per person for online orders within 30 days of purchase. Retail/in-store purchases must be handled through the retailer, and customers with damaged orders can contact care@getgorgie.com.
Poppi's return policy
Beverage returns are not accepted for products purchased from the website. Damaged or broken packages can be refunded or replaced upon contacting the company.
Keep comparing
