Outdoor Voices and Girlfriend Collective are both sustainable clothing brands that offer eco-conscious apparel and accessories. However, there are some key differences between the two.
Outdoor Voices, based in Austin, Texas, focuses on providing comfortable and functional clothing for an active lifestyle. Their products are sweat-wicking, thermoregulating, and anti-odor producing, making them ideal for physical activity. They also offer a wide variety of colors, patterns, and sizes, as well as free shipping on orders over $75 and student discounts.
On the other hand, Girlfriend Collective, founded in Seattle, prioritizes ethically made and eco-friendly activewear. Their collection includes tanks, tees, leggings, outerwear, and more, all made from re-purposed post-consumer plastic bottles. They also emphasize affordable prices and socially responsible production practices.
While both brands cater to customers who prioritize sustainability, Outdoor Voices appeals to those who value comfort and functionality in their clothing. With their focus on sweat-wicking and thermoregulating materials, Outdoor Voices is perfect for those leading an active lifestyle.
Meanwhile, Girlfriend Collective is ideal for customers who are environmentally aware and concerned about the impact of their consumption. By using re-purposed plastic bottles and practicing ethical production, Girlfriend Collective allows customers to make a positive impact on the planet through their fashion choices.
In summary, Outdoor Voices is a great choice for those seeking comfortable and functional activewear, while Girlfriend Collective offers eco-conscious and ethically made clothing at affordable prices. Both brands provide options for customers looking to prioritize sustainability in their fashion choices.
The bottom lineGirlfriend Collective edges ahead on value and sustainability (88/100 editorial score, lower price tier, higher sustainability rating) with faster shipping (1-4 days) and simpler returns for US customers. Outdoor Voices suits those prioritizing design heritage and technical apparel versatility, though it costs more and has sizing inconsistencies noted by both brands' reviewers. Both offer free shipping over $100 and strong comfort ratings, but Girlfriend Collective's 30-day hassle-free returns and included international duties make it easier for most shoppers.
Key differences at a glance
Girlfriend Collective scores higher on sustainability (95 vs. 90) and editorial quality (88 vs. 84), positioning as eco-conscious vs. Outdoor Voices' active/recreational focus.
Girlfriend Collective is significantly cheaper: $23–$118 typical range vs. Outdoor Voices' $16–$148, with Girlfriend Collective rated at pricing tier 40 vs. Outdoor Voices' tier 75.
Girlfriend Collective ships faster (1–4 business days) than Outdoor Voices (1–7 business days), with Girlfriend Collective's international orders including duties and taxes.
Girlfriend Collective's returns are simpler for US customers (30 days, unworn/unwashed, free exchanges/drop-offs) vs. Outdoor Voices' free returns but $25 fee for Canadian orders and no duty/tax refunds.
Both brands report sizing inconsistencies in customer reviews, but Outdoor Voices specifically criticized for small sizing and length issues for taller customers, while Girlfriend Collective noted for bra padding/slippin
Outdoor Voices offers more shipping speed options (2-day for $20, overnight for $30) vs. Girlfriend Collective's standard 7–10 day delivery.
Girlfriend Collective customer rating is 4.05/5 vs. Outdoor Voices' 4.4/5, with Outdoor Voices praised more for versatile styling across occasions.
They are light as air and by far the most comfortable pants I own. Truly the perfect thing to throw on in the summer.
Outdoor Voices verified buyer · via Okendo
4.4★★★★¼store rating · via Okendo
Outdoor Voices earns strong praise for comfortable, versatile clothing with great fabric quality, though some customers experience sizing inconsistencies and fit issues.
Customers love
Extremely comfortable and versatile pieces suitable for workouts, hiking, and casual wear
High-quality, soft fabrics with excellent stretch and durability through multiple washes
Flattering fits and stylish designs that work across multiple occasions
Watch out for
Sizing runs small and inconsistent across items; waistbands often tight or stiff
Length issues for taller customers; some styles discontinued in popular colors
Compression waistbands can be unflattering for some body types
I still have the leggings I got with the original Kickstarter about 10 years ago—these are that good!
Girlfriend Collective verified buyer · via Okendo
4.05★★★★store rating · via Okendo
Girlfriend Collective earns strong praise for comfort, durability, and quality, though some customers report fit inconsistencies and limited return/exchange policies.
Customers love
Exceptional comfort and softness that lasts through washing
Durable fabrics that hold up for years
Flattering fit with good support and no visible panty lines
Outdoor Voices's shipping policy Vs. Girlfriend Collective's Shipping Policy
Outdoor Voices's shipping policy
Standard shipping costs $7.98 or is free for orders over $100 in the U.S., with delivery in 3-6 business days via FedEx or USPS. Expedited options include 2-day shipping for $20 and overnight shipping for $30. Orders take 1-3 business days to pack and ship, or up to 7 business days during promotional or holiday periods.
Girlfriend Collective ships to the US, Canada, UK, and Australia. Orders ship within 1-4 business days, with delivery taking 7-10 business days for continental US, 7-10 business days plus 2 weeks for non-continental US/military, and 8-12 business days for Australia, UK, and Canada (with duties included).
Outdoor Voices's return policy vs Girlfriend Collective's Return Policy
Outdoor Voices's return policy
Outdoor Voices offers free returns for orders shipped to the United States that are not marked final sale. For orders shipped to Canada, Outdoor Voices only accepts returns on orders that don’t quite work out and there is a $25 flat fee that is deducted from the return when processed. Any duties and taxes paid will not be refunded. To return an item, customers must go to returns.outdoorvoices.com and enter their email. Outdoor Voices will send an email that links to the order history—next, select which items are being sent back and print a prepaid return label. All returns must be unworn, undamaged, and unwashed. Exchanges are not permitted for orders shipped to Canada, but customers can try a new colour/size for any style when selecting items that are being sent back. Outdoor Voices will ship the new colour/size right away. It typically takes Outdoor Voices up to 14 days to process a return. Final sale items cannot be returned.
Unworn, unwashed items with tags attached can be returned within 30 days of ship date for refund, exchange, or store credit. Mail-in refunds incur a $7 shipping and restocking fee, while exchanges and drop-off returns are free. Promotional purchases and final sale items are not eligible for returns.
