DTCetc score
FabFitFun82/100
Birchbox68/100
The DTCetc Face-Off Apparel · Beauty Updated July 2026
FabFitFun vs Birchbox
FabFitFun and Birchbox cater to customers who prioritize self-care and enjoy discovering new products, but they have slightly different approaches. FabFitFun offers a seasonal subscription box filled with full-size products across various lifestyle categories, allowing customers to elevate their lifestyle and stay ahead of trends. Birchbox, on the other hand, focuses solely on beauty and grooming products, offering a monthly subscription box with curated items to enhance customers' self-care routines. Both brands provide convenience and the excitement of unboxing surprises, making them great options for adventurous customers looking to enhance their self-care regimen.
Pricing tier
FabFitFun$$$$
Birchbox$$$
The verdict
Which should you pick?
The bottom lineFabFitFun suits shoppers seeking curated multi-category lifestyle boxes with wellness content access and a higher editorial quality score (82 vs. 68), though it charges a premium pricing tier and has a strict no-returns policy. Birchbox is better for beauty-focused discovery at a lower price point (tier 50 vs. 80) with intentional BIPOC brand partnerships and a 90-day return window on shop items, though subscription boxes themselves cannot be returned.
Key differences at a glance
- FabFitFun editorial score is 82/100 vs. Birchbox at 68/100; FabFitFun rates higher on quality (both 80) but FabFitFun also scores higher on sustainability (80 vs. 60).
- FabFitFun positions as a multi-category lifestyle membership (beauty, fashion, fitness, wellness, home, tech); Birchbox is beauty-only and emphasizes BIPOC-founded brand partnerships.
- FabFitFun pricing tier is 80/100 (premium); Birchbox pricing tier is 50/100 (mid-range).
- FabFitFun boxes ship within 30 days; Birchbox ships in 5–10 business days standard (or faster with paid expedited options).
- FabFitFun has an all-sales-final, no-returns policy on all products; Birchbox allows 90-day returns on shop items (though subscription boxes are non-refundable).
- FabFitFun includes access to FabFitFunTV streaming wellness content and members-only shopping; Birchbox does not offer these perks.
- FabFitFun delivers seasonally (4 boxes/year); Birchbox delivers monthly (12 boxes/year).
Still weighing it up? Save this comparison & get deals on both →
At a Glance
| Comparison Between |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Apparel | Beauty |
| Speciality | Clothing | Personal Care, Cosmetics, Bath & Body |
| DTCetc Score | 82/100 | 68/100 |
| Return window | — | 90 days |
| Stereotype | Modern | Self-care enthusiast |
| Pricing Rating | $$$$$
This brand is premium priced
| $$$$$
This brand is moderately priced
|
| Sustainability Score | 80/100
This brand scores excellent in sustainability
| 60/100
This brand scores good in sustainability
|
| Quality Score | 80/100
This brand scores excellent for product quality
| 80/100
This brand scores excellent for product quality
|
Want more comparisons like FabFitFun vs Birchbox?
Join free for the latest brands, comparisons & deals.
Who shops at FabFitFun Vs. Birchbox
Who shops at FabFitFun
FabFitFun is for people interested in curated lifestyle products and wellness content delivered on a seasonal basis.
Who shops at Birchbox
For people interested in discovering new beauty products tailored to their preferences.
FabFitFun Vs. Birchbox The Pros
FabFitFun's Pros
- Seasonal box includes full-size products across multiple categories
- Access to FabFitFunTV streaming wellness content
- Members-only shopping experiences
- Year-round perks beyond the box
- Online community access
Birchbox's Pros
- Monthly curated box delivery
- Intentional partnerships with BIPOC-founded beauty brands
- Focus on products that work and that customers love
- Emphasis on inclusive beauty standards
FabFitFun's shipping policy Vs. Birchbox's Shipping Policy
FabFitFun's shipping policy
Fabfitfun offers different shipping timelines depending on the type of order. FabFitFun Boxes, Add-Ons, Additional Choice items, Ship With Box Subscriptions, and Boost items generally ship within 30 days of the season's billing day. Edit Sale & Flash Sales orders ship within 14 days of successful billing, while Shop Orders ship within 5 business days. Drop Ship items will be shipped directly from the outside retailer within 3 weeks of billing. Shipping costs vary depending on the location. Continental US shipping for seasonal boxes and orders over $49 USD is free, while orders under $49 USD incur a $6.95 USD shipping fee. Shipping to Canada, Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico for orders over $49 USD is $8 USD, and orders under $49 USD incur a $14.95 USD shipping fee. UK shipping for orders over $49 USD is $5 USD, while orders under $49 USD incur an $11.95 USD shipping fee. Add-Ons always ship free with the box.
Birchbox's shipping policy
For domestic shipping, Birchbox US has a standard shipping rate of $5 (free with a purchase of $50 or more) and the delivery time is 5-10 business days. They also offer UPS Ground shipping for $7 and delivery in 1-5 business days, UPS 2nd Day Air for $15 in two business days, and UPS Next Day Air for $22 for next business day shipping (free with a purchase of $150 or more).For international shipping, Birchbox US does not currently ship outside of the United States. International purchases are made on their other platforms, like Birchbox UK, Birchbox Spain, and Birchbox France.
FabFitFun's return policy vs Birchbox's Return Policy
FabFitFun's return policy
FabFitFun's return policy states that all sales are final and the company does not accept returns or exchanges of any of their products, including FabFitFun Boxes, Add-Ons, Boost items, reFill items, additional choice items, Shop orders, or Edit/Flash Sale orders. Any returns made to the company will not be eligible for a refund. However, if there is an issue with a received order such as missing, damaged, lost, defective, or wrong/incorrect item(s), customers must report it within 2 weeks of the delivery date. Customers can contact the Customer Care Team via the black Support widget at the bottom of the screen to file a claim and/or get their items replaced. There is no information available on how long it takes the company to process a return. UK customers have a different Returns and Cancellation Policy applicable to their orders.
Birchbox's return policy
The return policy for Birchbox Subscription states that subscription boxes and gift cards are non-refundable, however products from the shop can be returned within 90 days of purchase. Shipping and handling fees are also non-refundable. To return an item, customers must contact Birchbox directly and follow their instructions. Returns are usually processed within 14 days of receipt.